Elections Intelligence

New York 17th District

DEFENDED SEATToss-up

Michael Lawler (R) has held this seat since 2023 and is running for re-election. Before that: Mondaire Jones (D).

Cait Conley Challenger
59¢
Party market · checked 2:09 PM ETView on Kalshi ↗
42¢
Michael Lawler Incumbent

FTP Race Signal

FTP Race SignalA composite of market, polling and money. The prediction-market price anchors it; a polling average moves it: the last 30 days, or the three most recent pollsters when fewer polled. Polls paid for by a candidate, party or allied group move 2 points toward the other side and count half. When the three most recent independent pollsters each have the race within three points, it is a Toss-up unless the market is already decisive. Fundraising counts only at a five-to-one gap. Past results are context, not inputs. A rating changes only when the evidence clears the line.

A seat that went Republican by 6 points in 2024 is now a coin flip, the Democrat narrowly ahead at 59¢.

Toss-up
Safe DLikely DLean DToss-upLean RLikely RSafe R
Market · Toss-upD 59¢: traders' price for a Democratic win, a flip from Republican. Polling · Toss-upR+1.3 (average of 3 pollsters, Sep 30). Prior result · Lean RR+6.31 in 2024.

Market favors Conley, but polls favor Lawler.

The market moved 6¢ toward the Republican in the last 7 days. As of October 12.

Market

BandPRICEToss-up50¢ to 65¢Lean65¢ to 82¢Likely82¢ to 95¢Safe95¢ and above
D 59¢

Kalshi party market · checked 2:09 PM ET

View market on Kalshi ↗

Polling

BandPOINTSToss-up0 to 5Lean5 to 10Likely10 to 20Safe20 and above
R+1.3
McLaughlin ↗ D Sep 28 to 30 · n=400 LV R+3 Lawler sponsor R+3 · Lawler sponsor · counts as R+1 at half weight
Emerson College ↗ A+ Sep 27 to 29 · n=400 LV D+2.3 Independent
co/efficient ↗ B Jul 20 to 22 · n=1,292 LV R+5 R-leaning firm

Average of the latest poll from each of the 3 most recent pollsters; fewer than three polled in the last 30 days. Polls paid for by a candidate, party or allied group move 2 points toward the other side and count half.

Earlier polls · 1
FM3 Research ↗ Jun 27 to Jul 1 · n=509 LV D+6 House Majority PAC sponsor D+6 · House Majority PAC sponsor · counts as D+4 at half weight

Prior result

BandPOINTSToss-up0 to 5Lean5 to 12Likely12 to 25Safe25 and above
R+6.3

Michael Lawler (R)

52.1% to 45.8% · 2024 general election

def. Mondaire L. Jones (D). Margin verified against retrieved official results.

Fundraising

BandRATIO TO 1Parity1 to 5Lean5 and above
1.8 to 1

Raised 2025 to 2026 · thru Jun 30

Cait Conley$4.32M ↗$1.32M cash
Michael Lawler$8.17M ↗$4.84M cash

Total receipts in the 2025 to 2026 two-year cycle, through June 30, 2026; Lawler leads 1.8 to 1, short of the 5 to 1 at which fundraising takes a place on the spectrum.

The general election is on November 3, which is 22 days away.